CompareImage model comparison

Ideogram V3 vs Recraft V4.1

Vizify's banner and poster tools name Ideogram V3 or Recraft V4.1 when a design carries visible headline or call-to-action text. The two are not interchangeable: Ideogram V3 also edits and reframes existing images, while Recraft V4.1 is prompt-only generation with wider ratio choices.

Capabilities reviewed 2026-09-26 · Evidence reviewed 2026-09-26

How this comparison was made

Method and test inputs

We compared the two models from a design-work angle: their generation catalog parameters, which Vizify image commands accept each model (generation, masked edit, reframe), and how the Site's poster and banner tools route text-heavy work. No test posters were generated and typography quality was not scored; no external benchmark is used.

  • Generation catalog parameters for ideogram-v3 and recraft-v4.1
  • Model lists for Vizify's image generate, edit, and reframe commands
  • Routing guidance in the banner and campaign-poster tool prompts
  • Ideogram and Recraft AI Image Generator tool contracts
Side by side

Ideogram V3 vs Recraft V4.1

CriterionIdeogram V3Recraft V4.1
InputText plus up to 1 reference image; a reference turns the request into a remixText only; no reference images
Output entry1K1MP (V4.1 Pro and Utility Pro list 4MP)
Aspect ratiosAuto, 1:1, 4:3, 3:4, 16:9, 9:16Auto, 1:1, 4:3, 3:4, 16:9, 9:16, 3:2, 2:3
Masked edit of an existing imageYes; Vizify's masked-edit command defaults to Ideogram V3Not supported
Reframe to a new aspect ratioYes; Vizify's reframe command runs only on Ideogram V3Not supported
Family in VizifyOne policyFive policies: V4.1, Pro, Flash, Utility, Utility Pro
Output formatRaster imageRaster image; no editable SVG or vector file is promised
Choosing

Which one fits your task

Option A

Ideogram V3

A single text-and-image policy at a 1K output entry. It accepts one reference image and is the model Vizify uses for masked edits and aspect-ratio reframes.

  • Designs with exact copy where one reference image sets the look
  • Changing a masked region of an existing design
  • Extending an existing graphic to a new aspect ratio

Reach for Ideogram V3 when the job touches an existing image — a masked fix, a reframe to another ratio — or when one reference picture should steer a new design.

Option B

Recraft V4.1

The standard policy of a five-model Recraft V4.1 family: text input only, a 1MP output entry, and eight aspect ratios including 3:2 and 2:3.

  • New designs described entirely in the prompt
  • 3:2 or 2:3 layouts, which Ideogram V3 does not list
  • Moving to a 4MP Recraft policy (V4.1 Pro) for a larger render

Reach for Recraft V4.1 when the whole design can be described in words and you need 3:2 or 2:3 framing, or want the option of a 4MP Recraft policy.

Before you rely on this

Current limitations

  • Neither model is promised to spell every word or place every element correctly; check copy, hierarchy, and layout in every result.
  • The comparison covers catalog parameters and command routing as of 2026-09-26, not rendered typography quality.
  • Recraft's other V4.1 policies and its background-removal and upscale utilities are outside this page.
  • Masked editing needs a mask that matches the source image's dimensions; without one, edit tools fall back to a semantic edit that may change nearby pixels.
  • A request runs on one model. Vizify does not produce an Ideogram and a Recraft version of a design in a single step.

Ideogram V3 and Recraft V4.1 turn up together because Vizify’s design tools pair them: when a banner or campaign poster carries a visible headline or call-to-action, the tools tell the Agent to use a graphic-design and text-rendering model such as Ideogram V3 or Recraft V4.1. Neither is promised to render lettering exactly, so the prompt should carry the exact copy and reading order either way.

Where they differ is what else they can do. Ideogram V3 takes one reference image, and it is the model behind two of Vizify’s image operations that start from an existing picture: masked edits, where a mask marks the region to change, and reframes, which extend an image to 1:1, 4:3, 3:4, 16:9, or 9:16. The AI Image Extender is built on that reframe path. Recraft V4.1 has none of this — it takes no reference images and only generates from the prompt.

Recraft’s advantages are in framing and family. It lists 3:2 and 2:3 on top of Ideogram’s six ratios, and its V4.1 family includes Pro and Utility Pro policies at 4MP if you need a larger render. Both return raster images; Vizify does not promise SVG or editable vector output from either.

FAQ

Questions about Ideogram V3 and Recraft V4.1

Which is better for typography, Ideogram V3 or Recraft V4.1?

Vizify has not measured that. Its banner and poster tools route text-heavy designs to either model, so give the exact copy and reading order in the prompt and check the result.

Can Recraft V4.1 use a reference image?

No. Every Recraft V4.1 policy in Vizify is text-input only. Ideogram V3 accepts one reference image, and a request with a reference runs as a remix.

Which model can edit part of an existing image?

Ideogram V3. Vizify's masked-edit command uses it by default, with a source image and a mask marking the area to change. Recraft V4.1 has no edit path in Vizify.

Can either model extend an image to a new aspect ratio?

Ideogram V3 can, through Vizify's reframe command, to 1:1, 4:3, 3:4, 16:9, or 9:16. The AI Image Extender tool uses this. Recraft V4.1 does not reframe.

Does Recraft V4.1 return an SVG in Vizify?

No. The Vizify contract returns a raster image and does not promise editable vector or SVG artwork.

What output size do they produce?

Ideogram V3 lists a 1K entry and Recraft V4.1 a 1MP entry. In the Recraft family, V4.1 Pro and Utility Pro list 4MP.

Do these models use the free image allowance?

Yes. A signed-in account has two free image generations, shared with edits and reframes; then Pro or a credit pack is required.

Related

Keep comparing

Start a design

Open Vizify and create your next banner or poster with Ideogram V3 or Recraft V4.1.